Recently, an FDA panel announced that Sudafed PE and other decongestants are, essentially, ineffective. Since this announcement, I’ve seen countless articles pop up on my Google News feed about removing Sudafed PE, Mucinex, and Benadryl from the shelves. The argument to remove the medicines is that we shouldn’t be selling ineffective products–but are they really ineffective? An argument can be made that these are exceptionally effective placebos (sugar pills/ineffective medicine).
The placebo effect is well documented; even when a patient knows they are taking a placebo, sometimes just taking a pill helps to trick the body into the desired effect. Bodies and minds are weird, and whatever works, works. Even if Sudafed and its relatives are little more than placebos, I think they should be allowed to stay on the shelves. After all, the placebo effect can reduce symptoms by up to 50%, and that’s more than enough to convince me.
For all the many ailments I have–visible and invisible, temporary and chronic–very few have effective and fast solutions. There is no Xanax for depression, no Zofran for migraines, but there is Sudafed for a stuffy nose. Maybe it’s silly to continue to take something that has been proven not to work, but I swear I feel my sinuses clear up minutes after taking Sudafed. It allows me to get a restful sleep instead of battling with the correct sleeping position that allows me to breathe.
With the lack of effective medications available for a variety of illnesses, I am frustrated by the attempt to remove existing medications instead of putting new ones on the market. While I am not necessarily a fan of being stuffed full of pills, I like having the hope that maybe there is an accessible medication out there that will work for me. When the number of approved medications is even further limited, frustrated and exhausted people like me turn to home remedies and endless concoctions of honey, sea salt, herbs, and usually get roped into the wellness industry once or twice.
If Sudafed doesn’t work for general populace, there is nothing I can do about it. But whether it’s the placebo effect at work or there really is some merit to Sudafed, let me decide how to spend my money. Taking Sudafed off the shelves leaves me one less remedy for a restful night–and when I’m combating so many other ailments for a moment of peace, this tiny relief is a huge victory for me. Leave the silly little pill on the silly little shelf and let me make my silly little choice; you are free to pass it in the aisle if you wish, but leave some for me.